John Morgan is a tax specialist lawyer of more than three decades experience now practicing at the Victorian Bar - w: www.FJMtax.com e: f.john.morgan@vicbar.com.au

Re Lack and FCT – Commissioner not out of time to issue assessments – sham conceded by taxpayers [38]

Husband and wife taxpayers who conceded that a “profit-washing” arrangement they entered into was a “sham” have been unsuccessful before the AAT in arguing that amended assessments were issued out of time and that 50% shortfall penalties for recklessness should have been remitted. The taxpayers operated a successful grain growing business in partnership and took…

Re Watsford and FCT – ESS: share options issued under a settlement were not new and the discount was assessable in the previous year [37]

The AAT has held a taxpayer was required to include a discount from the market value of shares he acquired on the exercise of options under an employee share scheme (ESS) in the 2007 year. It also upheld the Commissioner’s decision to impose a 25% shortfall penalty for failure to take reasonable care. The taxpayer…

Re Neimanis and FCT – Tax debt not released on hardship grounds despite tax payer having few assets in his name as his wife had assets [36]

The AAT has affirmed the Commissioner’s decision to refuse to release a taxpayer from an income tax and PAYG instalment debt pursuant to s 304-5 of the TAA as it considered the taxpayer would not suffer serious hardship. The taxpayer was a retired solicitor who had been in practice since 1979. He sought a release from…

Re Daniels and FCT – Taxpayer liable for $129k of CGT on disposal of Panamanian shares and a 50% shortfall penalty [34]

The AAT has affirmed the Commissioner’s decision that a taxpayer was liable for a capital gain made on disposal of shares in a Panamanian company for the 2006-07 income year. In addition, it also affirmed the 50% shortfall penalty imposed by the Commissioner. The Commissioner commenced an audit of the taxpayer’s affairs and associated entities…

*Re Building Company Owner and FCT – Discretion to disregard Div 7A not exercised in 2005, but was exercised in 2006 and 2007 for not properly documenting loans [31]

The AAT has exercised the discretion to disregard the operation of Div 7A on the grounds there was an honest mistake in not properly documenting loans by a private company to a shareholder. The taxpayer was a shareholder and director of a building company. In the 2005 income year, the company transferred money to the…

The Federal Magistrates Court will be re-named the Federal Circuit Court under the Federal Circuit Court of Australia Legislation Amendment Bill 2012 [29]

The Federal Circuit Court of Australia Legislation Amendment Bill 2012 has now passed all stages without amendment and awaits Royal Assent. The Bill will amend the Federal Magistrates Act 1999 and other legislation to rename the Federal Magistrates Court as the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, and to change the title of Chief Federal Magistrate…