*Symond v Gadens Lawyers Sydney Pty Ltd – solicitors gave negligent advice re withdrawing funds from company for tax purposes [45]

The NSW Supreme Court has held that solicitors who advised Mr John Symond, founder of “Aussie Home Loans”, were negligent in the advice they gave him in relation to a revised ownership structure to allow him access to funds in a tax advantageous manner for the construction of his new home but which, instead, resulted in a significant…

*DCT v Ekelmans & Ors – Final asset freezing orders postponed as they were “without legitimate purpose” until recovery process identified [44]

The Supreme Court of Victoria has held that asset freezing orders obtained by a Deputy Commissioner of Taxation were “without a legitimate purpose”. The Deputy Commissioner had brought proceedings under r 37A of the Supreme Court (General Civil Procedures) Rules 2005 (Vic) for freezing orders over assets to the approximate value of assessments issued to…

*Re Vision Intelligence Pty Ltd and FCT – R&D outgoing not incurred: taxpayer liable for 25% shortfall penalties [43]

The AAT has held the R&D expenditure claimed by a taxpayer was not incurred in the year ended 30 June 2009 and as such it affirmed the Commissioner’s decision to disallow the deduction and impose a shortfall penalty. The taxpayer was an Australian resident company operating in the engineering and software development surveillance industry. It had entered…

*Re Jakjoy Pty Ltd and FCT – CGT – properties used in ‘carrying on business’ of deriving rent not “active assets” – because of the ‘deriving rent’ exclusion [42]

The AAT has confirmed that the exclusion from the CGT small business concession in s 152-40(4)(e) of the ITAA 1997 for assets used “mainly to derive rent” applies (as intended) even if the assets are used in “carrying on a business” of a deriving rent. As a result, the AAT held that a range of commercial…

*Re Lambert and FCT – taxpayer’s plan to get negative gearing advantages through a discretionary trust fail [33]

The AAT has upheld the Commissioner’s decision to disallow the taxpayer’s claim for deductions for interest and bank fees of over id=”mce_marker”20,000 incurred [over 2 years] in relation to rental properties purchased by a family discretionary trust that had been set up for that purpose and of which he was the trustee. [The Taxpayer intended…